Lab-Grown Diamond vs Moissanite vs Cubic Zirconia: CVD, HPHT and Diamond Substitutes Compared

Lab-grown CVD diamond flower stud earring worn on the ear in natural sunlight

Five white stones can sit side by side in a shop window and look almost the same. Under the light of a restaurant, a wedding venue or a winter afternoon, they behave completely differently. This guide explains what each one is made of, how it handles light, how well it stands up to daily wear, and how to tell them apart, so you know exactly what you are paying for.

We work with natural gemstones and with lab-grown diamonds. We use lab-grown diamonds in our 925 silver jewellery as accent stones, to frame and highlight the beauty of natural colour gems, and we label every stone for what it is. Here is the plain-English science behind the choices you will see: lab-grown diamond (CVD and HPHT), moissanite, cubic zirconia, and the older substitutes such as white sapphire, YAG, GGG, strontium titanate and glass.

At a glance

Stone What it is Hardness (Mohs) Refractive index Dispersion (fire) Refraction
Lab-grown diamond, CVD Pure carbon (C), real diamond 10 2.42 0.044 Single
Lab-grown diamond, HPHT Pure carbon (C), real diamond 10 2.42 0.044 Single
Natural diamond Carbon (C), mined 10 2.42 0.044 Single
Moissanite Silicon carbide (SiC) 9.25 2.65 to 2.69 0.104 Double
Cubic zirconia (CZ) Zirconium oxide (ZrO₂) 8 to 8.5 2.15 to 2.18 0.058 to 0.066 Single
White sapphire Aluminium oxide (Al₂O₃) 9 1.76 to 1.77 0.018 Double
YAG Yttrium aluminium garnet 8.25 1.83 0.028 Single
GGG Gadolinium gallium garnet 6.5 1.97 0.045 Single
Strontium titanate SrTiO₃ 5 to 6 2.41 0.190 Single
Glass ("crystal", rhinestone) Silica-based glass 5 to 6 about 1.50 to 1.70 about 0.01 to 0.04 Single

Values are standard gemmological figures. Refractive index drives brilliance; dispersion drives "fire", the flashes of rainbow colour.

How light behaves inside each stone

Every white stone does three things with light. Brilliance is white light bounced back to your eye. Fire is white light split into spectral colours. Scintillation is the on-off sparkle you see when the stone or the light moves. The material sets the limits; the cutter decides how close the stone gets to them.

Brilliance: why refractive index matters

Refractive index measures how strongly a material bends light. The higher it is, the smaller the "critical angle", the angle beyond which light hitting an inside facet is reflected rather than escaping. Diamond's critical angle is about 24.4°, so a well-cut diamond traps light and returns it through the top. Glass, at around 41°, lets much of that light leak out of the back, which is why it looks glassy and flat.

Diamond (RI 2.42) Light reflects inside and returns to the eye Glass (RI about 1.5) Light escapes through the back of the stone

Refractive index compared (higher means more light returned)

Moissanite 2.67
Diamond (CVD/HPHT) 2.42
Strontium titanate 2.41
Cubic zirconia 2.16
GGG 1.97
YAG 1.83
White sapphire 1.77
Glass about 1.5

Fire: more is not always better

Dispersion is how widely a material fans white light into colours. Diamond's 0.044 gives a balanced mix of crisp white light and flashes of colour, the look people picture when they think "diamond". Moissanite has more than twice the dispersion (0.104), which reads as strong rainbow flashes, especially in sunlight; some people love it, others find it looks less like diamond. Strontium titanate goes further still (0.190), so far that it looks rainbow-coloured rather than white. Cubic zirconia sits a little above diamond. White sapphire, YAG and glass have very little fire, which is why they look clear but quiet.

Dispersion compared (the amount of rainbow "fire")

Strontium titanate 0.190
Moissanite 0.104
Cubic zirconia 0.062
GGG 0.045
Diamond (CVD/HPHT) 0.044
YAG 0.028
White sapphire 0.018

Single or double refraction

Diamond and cubic zirconia are singly refractive: light travels through them as one ray. Moissanite and sapphire are doubly refractive: each ray splits in two. Look through the top of a moissanite with a loupe at an angle and the back facet edges often appear doubled, a soft "fuzzy" look that a diamond never shows.

How hard is each stone, and why it matters

The Mohs scale ranks scratch resistance from 1 to 10. Everyday dust contains quartz, which is 7 on the scale, so anything softer than 7 will slowly scratch and dull, and even stones at 8 lose their crisp facet edges over years of wear. The scale is also not even: diamond at 10 is several times harder than sapphire at 9 in absolute terms.

Diamond (CVD/HPHT) 10
Moissanite 9.25
White sapphire 9
Cubic zirconia 8 to 8.5
YAG 8.25
Quartz dust 7
GGG 6.5
Glass, strontium titanate 5 to 6

The stones, one by one

Lab-grown diamond made by CVD

What it is: real diamond, pure carbon in the same crystal structure as a mined diamond. CVD stands for chemical vapour deposition. A thin diamond "seed" plate sits in a chamber filled with a carbon-rich gas such as methane and hydrogen. Microwave energy turns the gas into a plasma, and carbon atoms settle onto the seed one layer at a time, building a crystal over several weeks.

Why it looks the way it does: it has diamond's refractive index, dispersion and hardness, because it is diamond. Because the crystal grows in a carbon-and-hydrogen atmosphere rather than inside molten metal, CVD diamonds are typically very pure "type IIa" diamond, the chemically purest category, which in mined diamonds is rare. The growth is slow and controlled, and many CVD crystals are given a standard post-growth heat treatment to refine their colour, which grading reports disclose.

Living with it: hardness 10, no coating to wear off, no cloudiness with age, and the same care routine as any diamond. It is the lab-grown diamond we choose for the accent stones in our 925 silver jewellery, always clearly labelled lab-grown.

Lab-grown diamond made by HPHT

What it is: also real diamond. HPHT stands for high pressure, high temperature. The process recreates the conditions deep in the earth: a diamond seed and graphite sit in a press at around 1,300 to 1,600 °C and over 50,000 atmospheres, with a molten metal mix (often iron, nickel or cobalt) acting as a solvent that carries carbon to the seed.

What that means for you: optically and physically, a good HPHT diamond is diamond in every way. The difference is in the growth story. Because the crystal grows inside molten metal, HPHT diamonds can contain tiny metallic flux inclusions, and some respond to a strong magnet. Labs read these growth features to tell the two methods apart. Both are excellent; the CVD route simply grows diamond without a metal bath.

Moissanite

What it is: silicon carbide (SiC), a different material from diamond. Natural moissanite is found only in microscopic grains, so all gem moissanite is made in a lab.

How it handles light: a higher refractive index than diamond and more than twice the dispersion, so it shows bold rainbow flashes, plus double refraction that softens the look of the back facets. Some larger stones can show a faint grey or green tint in certain light.

Living with it: hard (9.25) and durable, a good material in its own right. It is simply not diamond, and its sparkle has a different character. It also conducts heat well, so it can fool a basic heat-only "diamond tester"; a combined thermal and electrical tester or a lab can separate it.

Cubic zirconia (CZ)

What it is: zirconium dioxide (ZrO₂), stabilised in a cubic crystal form with additives such as yttrium oxide. It is made by melting powder in a "skull" of its own material and letting crystals form as it cools.

How it handles light: a lower refractive index than diamond, so less brilliance, and a little more fire. When brand new and clean it can look bright from across a room.

Living with it: at 8 to 8.5 on Mohs, its facet edges round and scratch with daily wear, and it attracts grease that dulls it quickly. It is also very dense: a CZ weighs about 1.7 times as much as a diamond of the same size. Fine for costume jewellery and fashion pieces; not a stone that ages well.

White sapphire

What it is: colourless corundum (Al₂O₃), natural or lab-made, the same mineral as blue sapphire and ruby.

How it handles light: a much lower refractive index and very little fire, so it looks clear and calm, with a slightly "watery" sparkle next to diamond.

Living with it: hard (9) and durable, a respectable gem in its own right, but visibly different from diamond once you compare them side by side.

The older substitutes: YAG, GGG, strontium titanate and glass

  • YAG (yttrium aluminium garnet) was a popular imitation in the 1970s: reasonably hard, but low brilliance and little fire.
  • GGG (gadolinium gallium garnet) has more sparkle than YAG but is soft (6.5) and very heavy, and can darken in sunlight.
  • Strontium titanate matches diamond's refractive index but has such extreme dispersion that it looks rainbow-coloured, and at 5 to 6 on Mohs it scratches easily. It was sometimes used as the base of "doublets" capped with a harder stone.
  • Glass, sold as "crystal" or rhinestone, often relies on a reflective foil or coating behind the stone. It scratches with ordinary dust and loses its shine as the coating wears.

How to tell them apart

  • Breath test: breathe on the stone. Diamond disperses heat so fast that the fog clears almost instantly; on CZ, glass and most simulants it lingers.
  • Loupe check for doubling: doubled back facets point to moissanite or sapphire, not diamond.
  • Weight: CZ and GGG are much heavier than diamond for their size.
  • Testers: a heat-based tester separates diamond from CZ and glass, but moissanite can pass it; a multi-tester or lab is needed to rule moissanite out.
  • Lab identification: only a gemmological lab can confirm whether a diamond is natural or lab-grown, and whether it was grown by CVD or HPHT. Many lab-grown diamonds are laser-inscribed on the girdle with a report number and "lab-grown".

Which should you choose?

If you want the look, feel and lifetime durability of diamond, choose diamond. Lab-grown diamond gives you exactly that, real carbon crystal with diamond's brilliance, fire and hardness, at a fraction of the price of a mined stone of the same size. Among lab-grown diamonds, CVD is a clean, controlled way to grow it: carbon from gas, layer on layer, with no metal bath, typically resulting in very pure type IIa crystal.

Moissanite and white sapphire are durable alternatives with their own character. Cubic zirconia and the older substitutes are best kept for fashion jewellery you do not expect to wear for decades.

Whatever you choose, ask one question before you buy: "What exactly is this stone, and is that written on the receipt?" We label every stone in plain words: natural or lab-grown, and the treatment, if any.

Frequently asked questions

Is a lab-grown diamond a "real" diamond? Yes. It is carbon in diamond's crystal structure, with the same hardness, refractive index and dispersion as a mined diamond. The only difference is its origin, which must always be disclosed.

Is CVD better than HPHT? Both produce real diamond, and a well-made stone from either process can be beautiful. CVD grows diamond from carbon gas without molten metal, so stones are typically very pure type IIa crystal; HPHT stones can carry small metallic inclusions from their growth. Judge each stone on its own colour, clarity and cut.

Is moissanite a fake diamond? It is not a diamond, but it is not "fake" either: it is a real material, silicon carbide, sold under its own name. It becomes a problem only when it is sold as diamond.

Will cubic zirconia go cloudy? CZ does not turn cloudy on its own, but it scratches and picks up a film of oil and dust that dulls its sparkle, and its facet edges wear down over time.

Does a lab-grown diamond change over time? No. Like any diamond, it does not fade, cloud or lose its sparkle. Keep it clean and it will look the same in fifty years.

Questions about a stone you are considering? Message us and Leander will reply personally.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.